So, I guess it’s about time to talk about Dr. Strange. Honestly I’ve been kind of mixed on this whole project since
the beginning, and I say that as one of the few genuine Dr. Strange fans. I know a lot of folks are getting into
the sorcerer supreme now thanks to the publicity of the film production but
I’ve actually been a big fan of his since before the MCU got started and even I
was pretty skeptical about a Dr. Strange movie. The main reason for this is just that not every character or
comic can work across several mediums.
There are some comics that just only work as comics, the
same way there are TV shows or books that could only work and be as resonant as
they are in one particular medium.
It also didn’t help that I’m not really a Benedict Cumberbatch fan. Now we’ve got our first look at him in
costume along with some interesting concept art sketches and…while, I’m still
not convinced this is going to work it certainly looks more interesting than it
did before.
So this costume work is okay, kind of on the hokey side if
I’m being honest. The weird thing
about Dr. Strange as a character is that his costume is more of a ceremonial
garb than an actual costume so I get the inclination to revert to something
more cloth oriented for his visual design. He’s supposed to be wearing the sacred robes of the sorcerer
supreme so it makes some sense he’s got the kind of puffy shirt and flowing
cape combo of a LARPer in wizard wear.
However, a lot like the recent Daredevil costume this just doesn’t look
very impressive visually, mainly owing to how flaccid the fabric looks.
That’s part of the problem with trying to adapt Dr.
Strange’s comic costume directly; it was never designed for live action. In a comic book format Dr. Strange’s
cape and shirt have the perfect blend of flowing freedom and stiff rigidity
because they’re illustrated, in live action it all just sort of hangs there
limply. This was kind of the same
problem Green Goblin had in Spider-Man;
in the comics a latex facemask can move perfectly like a human face but in live
action it just looks weird. I do
like how much this costume looks like fantasy wizard gear rather than a
superhero suit but it’s very much a misfire for Marvel, much like the equally
unimpressive and ill-advised Daredevil costume.
It also doesn’t help that most of these pictures aren’t
really selling me on this vision of Dr. Strange and especially not on Benedict
Cumberbatch in the role. Dr.
Strange, as a character, has always occupied a weird niche in the Marvel
universe as he’s more adventuring wizard than superhero. What’s more, he’s one of the few heroes
who really doesn’t change much over the course of his origin story. Folks like Spider-Man or Iron Man,
their origin story is based around their powers coming at a traumatizing cost
that catalyzes them into heroics.
Dr. Strange is sort of the opposite, suffering a debilitating tragedy
that leads him to gain power. His
origin is that he was a brilliant but hedonistic surgeon who lost the precise
use of his hands after a car crash.
Seeking a cure in the mystic reaches of Tibet he was chosen
by the Ancient One to become Earth’s new Sorcerer Supreme, defender against all
mystic threats. What this
essentially means is that Dr. Strange learned magic entirely to avoid the consequences
of his cripplingly alcoholism and the whole “saving the universe” business was
just a happy accident.
In a lot of ways this leaves Dr. Strange half-way between
Tony Stark’s lovable drunk genius affect and the kind of bumbling jerk savior
of Ash from the Evil Dead
franchise. The problem is that
Benedict Cumberbatch isn’t really known for that kind of charming yet horrible
tight rope act. Even as Sherlock
Holmes he’s not really charming yet horrible, he’s just an ass and it’s his
occasional flourishes of limited humanity that are meant to make him more
engaging, and really Cumberbatch isn’t even that great at that particular
task.
Honestly, his best role
remains Captain Martin Crief on the British radio sitcom Cabin Pressure where he plays much more of a flustered every man
desperately in love with doing a job he’s not very good at. Now it’s possible this version of Dr.
Strange won’t be the lovable drunken sorcerer cad type but more of a somber and
cynical hero but I think that’d be a bit of a shame. Dr. Strange has always stood out when he was portrayed with
incredibly dry and sardonic wit, the times he slipped into colder aloofness
were always more tedious than anything else.
I will say that the effects work looks spot on and the
design of the Sanctum Sanctorum and the eye of Agamotto are both great. I really like the weird, circular
design around his hand magic, that’s very accurate to the kind of powers you’d
see Dr. Strange throw around in the comics. What’s more, the visualization of the astral plan looks
incredibly trippy and well realized, following the very surreal and
non-denominational designs from the classic comics.
Kevin Fiege has mentioned this film will be emphasizing
weird geometry and quantum physics as a kind of blend with magic, following the
templates laid down by Thor, and
that’s a good way of keeping with Dr. Strange’s exception from a hard and firm aesthetic
origin point for his magic.
Basically what I’m saying is that in the comics Dr. Strange’s magic
never looked overtly Hindu or Chinese or Native America, always very surrealist
and without direct parallel to real world cultures and they seem to have
captured that aesthetic very well here.
The eye of Agamotto, Dr. Strange’s necklace, is the big
stand out for a lot of people and it’s easy to see why. We all thought the eye had already
debuted in Thor as part of Odin’s
treasure vault alongside the evil eye, the casket of the ancient winters, and
the infinity gauntlet but this design is markedly smaller and different. It’s possible this is the same eye
pendant from Thor and Dr. Strange will be involved setting up
the events of Ragnarok, especially if Cate Blanchett turns out to be a more
universal threat and less Thor-centric, but I wouldn’t hold my breath on that
one. The major red flag here is
the glowing green stone in the heart of the eye, which is almost certainly an
Infinity Stone.
There are only two stones left unaccounted for in the Marvel
cinematic universe, the soul stone and the time stone, and given Dr. Strange’s
mystic origins and the fact Adam Warlock has yet to get even the slightest
mention for Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 2
this is probably the soul stone.
In the comics the Soul Stone’s base function is to steal people’s souls,
a pretty solid power for a character like Dr. Strange who’s already steeped in
magic and mysticism.
Given that
Marvel has to introduce the living humanoid embodiment of Death somewhere down
the line for Thanos to be in love with, having Dr. Strange flirt about with
stealing souls and the afterlife would be a good way to take the first step
towards that rather peculiar end goal.
If this is the soul stone I’d expect the time gem to be the very last
gem that’s being fought over in Infinity
War.
Overall I’m still not totally sold on Dr. Strange. It’s
become sort of an obnoxious truth of Marvel Studios that no matter how crazy
their endeavors seem they always succeed, to the point that it seems like the
safer, simpler stuff is more prone to failure.
I mean, the biggest failing of their entire run so far is
that some of their movies are too safe and formulaic, that’s a pretty shocking
flaw for a series that includes a talking raccoon and a guy called
Ant-Man.
In that spirit I think
it’ll be the stuff Dr. Strange tries
to play it safe on that sink the movie if it does turn out to be a
failure. Things like trying to
make Strange conform to the standard “asshole expert” persona that ballooned
out of Cumberbatch’s role on Sherlock
or downplaying the urban fantasy elements of his story in favor of something
more slick and broad reaching.
File this under we’ll see till the first trailers start to come
out.
Dr. Strange is
scheduled for release on November 4th, 2016
if you liked this article please like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter
if you liked this article please like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter
No comments:
Post a Comment